Recorded December 8, 2012
Christmas on Mars theme: Annie Savage
Sparks Nevada: Marc Evan Jackson
Croach the Tracker: Mark Gagliardi
The Red Plains Rider: Busy Philipps
Phillip Fathom: Hal Lublin
Tom Foolery: Zachary Levi
Mass Murderer: Matt Gourley
Deacon Structor: Mark McConville
Magesterio: Jeremy Carter
Gene Peeples: James Urbaniak
Pemily Stallwark: Molly Quinn
Joyce: Alessandra Torressani
Hammler: Keegan-Michael Key
Lizardman: Craig Cackowski
Frank: Paul F. Tompkins
Sadie: Paget Brewster
Santa: Scott Aukerman
Theodore: Jon Hamm
Music by Andy Paley and the Andy Paley Orchestra.
Guest-directed by Douglas Petrie.
Written by Ben Acker & Ben Blacker.
Beyond Belief, “Claus and Effect” guest-written by Ed Brubaker.